Caste’s Grip in 2025: Why Reservations Are Still India’s Fight for Justice | Dr. Raman Kumar

Introduction

In June 2025, a 15-year-old Dalit student in Mainpuri, UP, was beaten by his upper-caste teacher for touching a water bottle—fracturing his finger and jaw. His “crime”? Being Dalit. This incident shows that, despite constitutional guarantees, caste still governs dignity, education, employment, and safety.

Critics claim reservations for Dalits, Adivasis, and OBCs are outdated or unfair, pointing to the EWS quota as an alternative. But reservations aren’t about income—they’re tools to include the excluded (Thorat and Kumar 2009). The Mainpuri attack proves caste is ‘present’, not ‘past’. In 2025, the real question is not whether reservations are needed, but how to strengthen them against invisible forms of social exclusion, which includes caste based exclusion too.  

Caste’s Everyday Toll

Caste in India is not a relic of history—it is an everyday reality with brutal consequences. In Ahmedabad, Dalit workers are forced to wash their own cups because they are barred from using “upper-caste” utensils. In Madurai, Thevar landlords still treat  Dalits as bonded labourers, compelling them to dig graves without pay. (CJP 2025)

Between January and June 2025 alone, 113 atrocities against Dalits were recorded: 26% physical assaults, 20% murders, and 19% sexual violence. Recent cases show the scale of humiliation—from Dalit men in Odisha being shaved, forced to crawl, and made to drink sewage, to a Dalit wedding procession in Uttar Pradesh attacked with casteist slurs. (CJP 2025)

Statistics echo these lived realities. Thirty percent of Dalit families and 40% of Adivasi families remain below the poverty line, compared to 17% of upper caste Hindus. Dalits and Adivasis account for barely 5% of faculty in elite institutions like IITs. Crimes against Dalits rose to over 58,000 cases in 2022—a 25% jump. Tragedies like the suicide of Dr. Payal Tadvi in 2019 show that caste follows people even into elite spaces.

Caste today is not invisible if you have the clear vision—it is violence, deprivation, and exclusion repeated daily across India. It is manifested in various indicators like occupational pattern, ownership of agricultural land, income, unemployment, poverty, literacy, health, status, and access to civil amenities (Dalits in India book by Sukhadeo Thorat). In fact, the oppression is so strong that it is considered as ‘normal’.

Why Caste Hierarchy Persists

Caste hierarchy survives because it protects entrenched privilege. Those at the top consolidate power, while Dalits remain trapped in degrading, underpaid work such as sewer cleaning and farm labour. Hinduism historically reinforced this hierarchy, dictating who could eat, live, or work where.

As Ambedkar argued in Annihilation of Caste, caste is a “system of graded inequality”—not just a division of labour, but of labourers.

Institutions and party politics also keep caste alive. Elections mobilize caste identities instead of dismantling them. Police often side with dominant castes—nine of 113 atrocities against Dalits in early 2025 involved police violence, while several others saw no action at all. In Uttar Pradesh, upper castes dominate 23 of 80 parliamentary constituencies, curbing Dalit representation. From village wells to marriage apps, caste adapts with time because it continues to serve the privileged few.

Reservations as Social Justice

Reservations are not charity but structural tools to include the excluded, be it caste or ethnicity or gender. For nearly two millennia, Dalits were denied land, education, and dignity. The Constitution sought to correct this: Articles 15 and 16 prohibit discrimination and enable affirmative action, while Article 46 directs the state to uplift SCs and STs.

Initially for SCs and STs, reservations later included OBCs after the Mandal Commission (1990), always with the same purpose—social justice, not poverty relief. As Ambedkar envisioned, they ensure dignity, representation, and access to excluded institutions.

Democracy thrives only when all voices are represented. As Iris Young argued, justice means not just equality on paper but deliberate inclusion of the historically silenced. In India, reservations remain one of the major tools that make this inclusion real.

Reservations’ Impact

Reservations have opened doors once shut to Dalits, Adivasis, OBCs and women. Success stories—like Tina Dabi, a Dalit woman who topped the IAS in 2015, and Mangala Muduli from the Bonda tribe cracking NEET in 2024—show how talent flourishes when barriers fall. They have expanded marginalized presence in legislatures, universities, and public jobs, offering visibility and hope.

Yet discrimination persists. A Dalit IAS officer humiliated by an upper-caste politician in 2016 shows bias lingers even in elite spaces. In 2025, the gang rape and mutilation of a tribal woman in Madhya Pradesh revealed how caste and gender intersect violently. Structural issues like landlessness, poor schools, and everyday violence remain beyond quotas’ direct reach. Larger social change is required for that.

Women’s reservation in Panchayati Raj proves representation can shift grassroots power, though tokenism and resistance persist. Today, we are talking about representation of women in both state and central legislatures. Likewise, reservations are an entry point, not a cure-all. They create access and dignity but must be backed by broader reforms—land rights, quality education, gender justice, and strict anti-discrimination enforcement.

The EWS Flaw

The 103rd Amendment (2019) introduced the EWS quota for economically weaker upper castes—breaking from Ambedkar’s vision of reservations as redress for including the excluded. This was meant as a matter of group rights and intended for social groups, not economic group. Earlier economic quotas like the 1991 Narasimha Rao attempt were struck down in Indra Sawhney (1992), yet the Supreme Court’s Janhit Abhiyan (2022) verdict upheld EWS, shifting the logic of social justice to income criteria. This dilutes reservations’ transformative purpose, as scholars note exclusion is rooted in group identities, not poverty. Practical flaws make it worse: a high income cap that favors upper-caste middle classes, rampant fraud in certification (Mumbai, Gujarat), and persisting caste violence—with 96% of SC and 95% of ST atrocity cases pending in 2025. By legitimizing privilege, EWS turns reservations from a tool of social inclusion into an economic concession, undermining the fight against entrenched caste hierarchies and other forms of social exclusion like patriarchy.

Debunking Anti-Reservation Myths

People always criticize reservations due to lack of awareness. Here are a few such myths

Myth 1: “Quotas destroy merit.”

As Sukhadeo Thorat explains, merit cannot be separated from social context. Reservation is given in elected bodies, government jobs and education. Privileged castes long monopolized good schools, coaching, and networks, while SC/ST/OBC students faced underfunded institutions and exclusion. Reservations don’t dilute merit—they expand opportunity by correcting these unequal starts. It is one of the best means to counter discrimination. Success stories like Tina Dabi (Dalit IAS topper, 2015) and Mangala Muduli (Bonda tribal NEET qualifier, 2024) show talent thrives when barriers fall. Such achievements exist not “despite” but because of reservations, and opposition often reflects discomfort with redistributing opportunity, not a defense of merit.

Myth 2: “Reservations Divide the Country”

It is caste—not reservations—that has historically fragmented India, shaping where people live, marry, work, and access justice. Recent incidents, like the assault on a Dalit student in Mainpuri (June 2025) and the humiliation of Dalit men in Odisha over false cow-smuggling charges (CJP, 2025), highlight caste’s enduring power. 

Reservations are corrective, not divisive. It tries to unite the country by including every excluded group. As Ambedkar argued in Annihilation of Caste, caste fixes human worth by birth, requiring safeguards for dignity and representation.

Myth 3: “Rich Dalits Misuse Reservations”

The claim that affluent Dalits exploit reservations overlooks a key reality: caste discrimination persists despite financial success. For instance, a Dalit CEO in Bengaluru hides his caste to avoid losing clients, showing how stigma survives wealth. This shows that no matter how much money a Dalit earns, society still sees caste first and talent or success second. Reservations give Dalits a fighting chance against the social barriers that money alone cannot erase.

The argument also collapses when compared to gender: educated, independent women still face patriarchy. Hence, political reservations for women is essential. Similarly, caste-based reservations counter deep structural barriers.

Myth 4: “Caste Discrimination Is Over”

The belief that caste discrimination has ended — and thus reservations are obsolete — is contradicted by contemporary realities. Caste-based violence remains rampant: in Rasra, Uttar Pradesh, a Dalit wedding was attacked with caste slurs, and in Muzaffarpur, Bihar, a Dalit girl was raped (June 2025). Such incidents show that caste oppression persists as a lived reality of humiliation, exclusion, and violence.

Research supports this. Thorat et al. (2006) reveal that discrimination against Dalits continues not only in villages but also in urban labour markets, housing, and access to services. Caste bias affects hiring, renting, and even market transactions, proving that exclusion extends beyond tradition into modern institutions.

If caste bias were truly over, India would not witness tens of thousands of caste atrocity cases annually, nor would Dalit and Adivasi communities face disproportionately higher poverty, illiteracy, and malnutrition rates. Reservations, therefore, remain essential — not only as compensation for historical wrongs but also as structural tools to combat ongoing caste-based inequalities.

Myth 5: “Poor Upper Castes Suffer Because of Reservations”

Reservations are tools of social justice, not poverty relief. Poor upper castes already have the EWS quota (2019), but it is conceptually flawed, this shift focus from caste-based exclusion to income, a role better handled by welfare measures like housing, healthcare, and subsidies. As Anne Phillips (1995) argues in The Politics of Presence, representation is about dismantling systemic barriers, not redistributing welfare. Just as women’s political quotas exist despite class differences, caste-based reservations remain essential to ensure true inclusion and representation, regardless of economic status.

Job Scarcity, Not Reservation, Is the Real Crisis

The perception that reservations “take away seats” ignores the real problem: chronic unemployment. In 2022, over 12.5 million candidates competed for just 35,000 railway posts, highlighting structural job scarcity. Scrapping reservations won’t create opportunities—it only masks systemic failure.

What India needs is large-scale job creation. Countries like Sweden and South Korea show that welfare, industrial growth, and state-backed training can absorb youth into productive work. Ambedkar envisioned similar state-led industrialization as the backbone of social democracy.

Reservations must remain as safeguards against caste inequality, but lasting solutions require public investment and a welfare state that guarantees dignified employment. When jobs are abundant, resentment over reservations will fade, and collective prosperity can advance.

Beyond Reservations

Reservations are vital but not enough. There are major limitations to the current form of reservations. Women get 33% reservation in local bodies, but not in state and central legislatures. Dalits and Adivasis get nominal representation in legislatures, not real. Religious minorities do not get any form of reservation at all (Hasan, 2009). No one talks about private sector jobs where discrimination is equally present. Caste inequality is too deep to be undone by quotas alone. Land redistribution, quality public education, healthcare, and social security are essential to break the cycle of poverty and dependence. 

Stronger anti-discrimination enforcement is equally crucial. Laws like the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act must be implemented without delay or dilution. Social awareness campaigns, curriculum reforms, and inter-caste solidarity movements can challenge stigma at its roots.

True equality requires both structural reforms and cultural change. Reservations open doors, but India must also build systems that guarantee dignity and opportunity for all.

Conclusion

The 2025 Mainpuri assault shows caste is not history—it’s lived reality. Despite constitutional guarantees, Dalits, Adivasis, and women still face violence and exclusion. Reservations remain one of the few tools that ensure dignity, representation, and access.

The real crisis is scarce jobs, weak welfare, and poor law enforcement—not quotas. Ending reservations would erase hope, not caste. India must strengthen them alongside reforms in land, education, employment, and justice. Discrimination won’t disappear on its own; only deliberate structural action anchored in reservations can fulfill the Constitution’s promise.

Break caste. Keep the promise. Let birth never decide destiny.

References
  • Citizens for Justice and Peace (CJP). (2025). “Everyday Atrocity: Mapping the normalisation of violence against Dalits and Adivasis in 2025.” July 5, 2025. 

Link: https://cjp.org.in/everyday-atrocity-mapping-the-normalisation-of-violence-against-dalits- and-adivasis-in-2025/

 

  • National Sample Survey Office (NSSO), 2019–20.

 Link:    https://www.mospi.gov.in/sites/default/files/publication_reports/Annual_Report_2019- 2020_English.pdf

  • National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), 2020–21. 

Link:  http://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/FR375/FR375.pdf

Link: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/289108184_Justice_and_The_Politics_of_Difference

  • Ambedkar on Social Exclusion and Inclusion by S. Thorat and N. Kumar

Link: https://l1nk.dev/9jE2S

  • Politics of Inclusion (2009) by Zoya Hasan

Link: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/354576838_Review_Essay_Politics_of_Inclusion_2009_by_Zoya_Hasan

  • Annihilation of Caste B.R. AMBEDKAR

Link: https://sl1nk.com/NFJJt

  • Democracy and the Representation of Difference by Anne Phillips

Link: https://l1nq.com/akAmW

  • New form of youth participation and work in Sweden

Link: https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000067491

  • Role of education and industrial policy in the republic of korea’s economic development by Abhijeet etal Link: https://sl1nk.com/c9NAr
About the Author

Dr. Raman Kumar is a dental surgeon and public health professional, currently pursuing an MDS at Indira Gandhi Government Dental College, Jammu. He holds a BDS from BFUHS and an MPH from CSMCH, JNU. His interests include caste, health equity, and inclusive development.

Share