Social Determinants and Road Traffic Accidents: Road Safety through a Safe Systems Approach
Abstract: Sustainable Development Goal 3.6 aims to halve the global road traffic injuries and fatalities by 2030. India alone accounts for nearly 10 per cent of these deaths, with road accidents disproportionately affecting different categories of road users. Addressing this challenge requires attention not only to policy and infrastructure gaps but also to the underlying socio-economic factors. This article examines the social determinants influencing road safety in India, along with the economic and gender-based implications of road accidents. It offers a comprehensive perspective on advancing road safety through the Safe Systems Approach, situated within the broader Indian context.
Keywords: Sustainable Development Goal 3.6 (SDG 3.6), Road Traffic Accidents (RTAs), Road Safety, Safe Systems Approach, Rural-Urban Divide, India 2030 Agenda, Gender and Road Accidents.
Commentary
The pace of a country’s progress is driven by seamless connectivity. In this context, each year, countless roads, highways and freeways are constructed to boost connectivity, facilitate mobility and foster socio-economic development around the world. Roads are the connecting link to progress and development, yet road safety remains a major issue worldwide. Road Traffic Accidents (RTAs) cause over 1.9 million fatalities globally and leave between 20 and 50 million people with non-fatal injuries each year, especially among children and young adults of the age group 5-29 years (World Health Organisation, 2023a). Globally, young male adults aged 25 or less are at a 2.7 times higher risk of fatality due to RTAs as compared to their female counterparts (Yan & Facrs, 2024). Having said that, Sustainable Development Goal 3.6 (SDG 3.6) set a target to halve the global deaths due to road traffic accidents by 2030.
Statistically, nine out of ten global deaths due to RTAs happen in low and middle-income countries (LMICs) that own nearly 60 per cent of the world’s vehicles. The number of road accidents is disproportionately higher in rural areas, particularly among the more vulnerable, which include the pedestrians, the cyclists and the motorcyclists (ibid). Thus, there is a need to understand the key social determinants related to road traffic accidents.
In the Indian context, the country accounts for 10 per cent of global deaths due to RTAs, despite owning only 1 per cent of the world’s vehicles (World Bank, 2021), which further proves that there is need to understand underlying social factors affecting RTAs. The current data shows that over 1,50,000 people lose their lives to road accidents annually, which means a staggering 400+ deaths each day (World Health Organisation, 2023b). A large majority of road fatalities in India affects males (86.2 percent) as compared to females (13.8 percent). A recent study highlights that while the country has made remarkable progress on several health indicators from 1990 to 2021, the death rate from road traffic injuries (across all ages and gender) increased by 6.3 percent (Tiwari. G et.al, 2024). RTAs cost India a loss of 3 percent of its Gross Domestic Product, making it a socio-economic crisis (Biswas, 2025). In addition to the healthcare costs incurred after the accidents, the economic burden on a family is also increased due to the loss of productivity for the accident victims and their caregivers, as they often give their work priorities a back seat to focus on providing care for the RTA victim (World Health Organisation, 2023). This results in a significant decrease in the family income, ultimately impacting the national economy.
In context to the states in the country, a recent report by the Government of India’s Ministry of Road Transport and Highways reported Tamil Nadu (13.9 percent) as the state with the highest number of RTAs, followed by Madhya Pradesh (11.8 percent) and Kerala (9.5 percent) respectively. Considering fatality, Uttar Pradesh recorded the maximum number (13.4 percent), followed by Tamil Nadu (10.6 percent) and Maharashtra (9 percent) respectively. In contrast, the north-eastern states and union territories such as Chandigarh and Lakshadweep have recorded fewer accidents and accident-related deaths (Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, 2023).
Considering the rural-urban divide, it was observed that 68 percent of fatalities due to RTAs happened in rural areas, while the urban areas accounted for 32 percent of accident-related deaths (ibid). Victims from rural and lower socio-economic strata are also more likely to face vulnerability, which includes disability of various kinds. This vulnerability is exacerbated by an interplay of various factors, including income disparity, lack of proper education, employment, healthcare and infrastructural facilities in the rural areas. The economic repercussions of RTAs are particularly adverse for rural low-income households, showcasing a 56 per cent decrease in family income. Similarly, the income of urban low-income households can drop significantly (29.5 percent) after road accidents (World Bank, 2021).
In rural India, the dangerous combination of poor roads and infrastructure, unregulated traffic, lax enforcement of road safety rules, low public awareness and delayed post-trauma care puts rural victims at an increased risk of accidents and accident-related deaths (ibid).
While the urban milieu offers ambulances and faster trauma response, it poses a different set of challenges for the underprivileged. Public transportation systems in most Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities are still underdeveloped. Currently, 24 Indian cities have a Mass Rapid Transit System (MRTS) while 16 have only a single rapid transit system in the form of metro rail or Bus Rapid Transit (BRT). Only five cities have a combination of more than one rapid transit system. Of the cities that have metro rail-based transit systems, most report low ridership, while the volume of bus commuters is higher in cities with BRT. Despite the demand for buses, the cities fail to comply with the minimum fleet size guidelines of the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs and continue to over-emphasise the need for developing metro rail-based transportation. This compounds the issue of a lack of adequate public transportation systems to cater to the population of these cities, resulting in more vehicles on the road and traffic congestion (Dawda, 2024).
Furthermore, rapid urbanisation also leads to congestion, along with other issues such as over speeding, driving under influence, distracted driving due to smartphone usage, along with a rise in two-wheeler drivers mainly from the upwardly mobile sections of the society. These road dynamics put the vulnerable users like pedestrians, two-wheeler users and those crowded into shared autorickshaws at an increased risk of crash injuries and death (ibid). This further underscores the need to transition to a more inclusive road safety system which prioritises equitable protection for all road users.
In addition to the spatial and socioeconomic divide, there is a broad gender gap regarding RTAs in India. Road accidents impact men and women in distinct ways. India has low female labour force participation and women are largely excluded from social and economic life due to prevalent socio-cultural biases. This means that they travel less and commute shorter distances as compared to men. Since men use the roads more, they are at a higher risk of road accidents. However, in the event of an accident, women are at greater risk of fatality and less likely to receive care and treatment. Moreover, the entire family of the victim tends to bear the financial implications of RTA, with the situation being harder for women owing to lack of financial autonomy. Also, given their traditional role as primary caregivers, they must bear the additional responsibility of taking care of the victim. Thus, while men are affected directly, women are also adversely impacted due to loss of household income, further compromising their physical, mental and financial well-being (Yan & Facrs, 2024).
The regulatory mechanisms pertaining to road safety in India include Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act 2019, National Road Safety Policy 2010 and various other schemes such as the National Highway Accident Relief Service Scheme (NHARSS), which emphasise on safety standards in motor vehicles, govern the registration and licensing of motor vehicles and provide measures for assistance to crash victims. The 4Es framework, including Education, Engineering (both of roads and vehicles), Enforcement and Emergency Care emphasises on safer roads, but the implementation remains patchy (Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, 2023).
There are directives from the government through policies and schemes; however, enforcement is lacking. Use of safety helmets, seatbelt compliance and traffic rules are not strictly followed. Road audits are not regular, the quality of construction is poor, and engineering is copied from the Western countries and not sensitive to the needs of Indian road users. Indian roads witness a diverse array of road users, from bullock carts to two-wheelers to luxury car drivers. While the west-inspired road infrastructure is rapidly expanding, it fails to account for the heterogeneous traffic environment on local roads. For instance, building wider roads without enforcing strict road regulations or including pedestrian-friendly crossings can lead to more over speeding and hence more risk for pedestrians and cyclists (ibid), (Biswas, 2025).
The discussion above broadens our focus from the traditional narratives revolving around the road user behaviour to devising a more comprehensive strategy for road safety. The Safe Systems Approach endorsed by WHO teaches us to share the onus of road safety between road users, policymakers and authorities. With a focus on empathy and equity, it emphasises three key points: humans make mistakes, the human body is fragile, and road safety systems must be engineered to protect all people, especially the vulnerable. The approach imbibes lessons such as lowering the urban speed limits, providing adequate street lighting, prioritising the pedestrians, strong law enforcement and quick post-trauma care from countries like Norway, the United Arab Emirates and Belarus that have reduced their road traffic fatalities by half (World Health Organisation, 2023a). This raises the question of whether such measures could address India’s road safety challenges.
The following section outlines some key components of the safe systems approach that can benefit the Indian roads and help India ensure road safety for all.
Navigating the Road Ahead
Experts argue that despite the length of roads constructed across India, the road traffic fatalities continue to rise because of the faulty design and inadequate infrastructure. India must employ dependable safety engineering mechanisms and crash data science. Indian roads must have safe crossings, footpaths and cycle lanes to ensure the safety of cyclists and pedestrians (Biswas, 2025). The road audits should be regularised and decentralised to local authorities. Additionally, public health policies must provide free safety gear, such as good-quality helmets and child safety systems, making it accessible to people from all socioeconomic strata.
To foster community engagement for first response systems, local resources must be identified and trained in first aid and integrated into trauma care delivery systems to ensure faster post-trauma response. In addition to this, stricter enforcement of traffic rules and widespread mass education campaigns promoting responsible road behaviour, as well as legal, medical and financial literacy in the event of a crash, can help victims or their kin navigate the complex situation.
India also needs to integrate the use of technology and data for improving road safety. Data amalgamation not only helps to understand information of road safety but also helps to identify trends which are necessary for progress towards road safety. The Government of India has launched the Electronic Detailed Accident Report (e-DAR), a mobile application-based platform that allows the first responders, generally the police, to input accident data. This app uses geo-tagging and multimedia reports to generate a unique identity number for each crash. This data is then analysed to identify areas for improvement. Additionally, this allows for faster processing of financial claims and fact-checking. Capacity-building programs targeting first responders to promote the efficient use of this app can bridge data gaps.
For a holistic redressal of the issue, addressing the huge gender bias in road safety is important. India requires a comprehensive gender-sensitive road safety policy that acknowledges the distinct ways road accidents impact men and women. To bridge the gender gap pertaining to road accidents, short-term measures such as widespread behavioural education to promote responsible road use, particularly targeting the males, must be combined with improved road infrastructure tailored to the local environment and efficient post-trauma care. Access to safe public transportation facilities is essential to facilitate women’s mobility for education, employment, healthcare and other important services. Additionally, empowering women through education about their legal and financial rights can enable them to navigate such challenging situations more confidently. The long-term efforts in this regard should focus on eliminating disparities across sectors, such as education, employment, and finances. A multifaceted intersectional approach is key to addressing the issue effectively.
Conclusion
In conclusion, a multi-pronged strategy embedded in safe systems approach can help India attain its goal of ensuring road safety for all. Mass education initiatives and stricter enforcement of road regulations are crucial, along with the integration of advanced technology into road safety systems. Moreover, addressing systemic inequities, including socio-economic and gender disparities, is an essential long-term measure.
Whether or not India meets the SDG 3.6 will not be decided in boardroom meetings or conferences. It will be decided on the vast network of its roads, from the remote villages in the periphery, where silences follow a crash and victims go unseen. Every policy that encompasses a remote village, every helmet that reaches a rural household and every road design that fits the local needs brings us one step closer to the goal. India’s road safety statistics echo its social justice issues. For India to get past the SDG 3.6 target, we must develop empathy for those we have overlooked, provide an equal voice to the unheard in our policies, and empower and integrate our systems to bridge all divides.
Authors’ Bios:
Navsangeet Saini is a communication professional with over 13 years of experience across academia,communication research, and writing. She holds a Ph.D. in Mass Communication, with research interests in gender representation in media, media democracy and media as an agent of change. Currently, in her role as writer at Max Institute of Healthcare Management- Indian School of Business, she spotlights key issues in healthcare.
Chaitra Khole is working as the Associate Director at the Max Institute of Healthcare Management at the Indian School of Business. She holds a Ph.D. from the Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS), Mumbai. With an experience of more than 13 years, she is an academician with a keen interest in public health domains focusing on geriatrics, nutrition, health systems strengthening, and healthcare management.
References:
- World Health Organization. (2023). Global status report on road safety 2023. https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/375016/9789240086517-eng.pdf?sequence=1
- Traffic Crash Injuries and Disabilities: The Burden on Indian Society (Vol. 1 of 7) (English). Washington, D.C.: World Bank Group. (2021) http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/761181612392067411
- World Health Organization. (2023b). Global status report on road safety 2023. https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/country-profiles/road-safety/road-safety-2023-ind.pdf?sfvrsn=b4fb5a5c_3&download=true
- Tiwari, G., Goel, R., Agrawal, G., Singh, N., and Bhalla, K., 2024, India Status Report on Road Safety: 2024, Transportation Research & Injury Prevention Centre, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi.
- Biswas, S. (2025, April 21). Why India’s roads are among the world’s deadliest. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4g49pgx6d0o
- Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. (2023). Road Accidents in India 2022. https://morth.nic.in/sites/default/files/RA_2022_30_Oct.pdf
- Dawda, N. (2024, February 12). A matter of choice: Determining public transport systems for urban India. orfonline.org. https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/a-matter-of-choice-determining-public-transport-systems-for-urban-india
- Yan, W., & Facrs, S. J. B. P. G. (2024, March 16). Road crashes affect women and men differently—here’s why. World Bank Blogs. https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/endpovertyinsouthasia/road-crashes-affect-women-and-men-differently-heres-why
World Health Organization. (2023, December 13). Road traffic injuries. World Health Organization. https://www.who.int/news-oom/fact-sheets/detail/road-traffic-injuries



