Keywords – Manual Scavenging, income, poverty, social location.
Introduction
In this paper, I will try to link it with how the problem of income leads to the people belonging to the Manual Scavenging community to remain stuck in the traditional occupation. Despite their best efforts, they are unable to step out of this vocation. The term development in a simple and easy language, means growth and evolution. Every individual in her life wants to achieve a growth for significant reasons such as better sustainable life, good education, better living conditions, a home. But to fulfill all these one needs is a good source of income. To fulfill all the above given prospects one relies on good income.
Manual Scavenging
The official website of Ministry of Social Justice provides definition of a Manual Scavenger which is as follows: “Manual Scavenger” means a person engaged or employed by an individual or a local authority or a public or private agency, for manually cleaning, carrying, disposing of, or otherwise handling in any manner, human excreta in an insanitary latrine or in an open drain or pit into which the human excreta from insanitary latrines is disposed of, or on a railway track or in such other spaces or premises, as the Central Government or a State Government may notify, before the excreta fully decomposes in such manner as may be prescribed, and the expression “manual scavenging” shall be construed accordingly.”
Critical analysis of various Committees and Policies introduced Post – Independence.
The first committee which took the initiative to work against this evil practice of manual scavenging was The Barve Committee ,1949-1951. The committee was known as the Scavengers’ Living Conditions Enquiry Committee in 1949. Its Chairman was Shri V. N. Barve. The role of this committee was to study and inquire into the living conditions of the scavengers in the state of Bombay, and recommendations were made to improve the living conditions and fix a minimum wage.
The Kaka Kalelkar Commission, 1953 – It was the First Backward Classes Commission appointed in1953 under the Chairmanship of Kaka Kalelkar. This commission suggested the living and working conditions of the scavengers as sub –human. Because of the recommendations of Kalelkar Commission, the State Governments by the Ministry of Home Affairs in October 1956 started giving prominence on the need to promote the mechanical and new up-to date methods of sanitizing the latrines.
Malkani Committee, 1957- This committee was constituted under the Chairmanship of Prof. N. K. Malkani in 1957.It is also known as Scavenging Conditions Inquiry Committee and it suggested to introduce a scheme to put a ban on this filthy practice of carrying night soil in buckets or baskets which the people had to carry on their heads. I would like to take the suggestions made by the above agencies with the view that they somehow missed the significant aspects of culture and stigmas and growth in income. All the policy makers while constituting these committees somehow failed to recall the crucial aspect of why a particular section of the society is still pursuing such a filthy and humiliating profession. Determining and acknowledging a fix wage for the scavengers was certainly a substantial step towards resolving the problems of wages associated with scavengers. However in the long run the problem remains exactly the same as they are unable to get out of this ruthless and circle of humiliation. Not earning a decent amount of income leads them to remain stuck at the ends of the social hierarchy.
THE EMPLOYMENT OF MANUAL SCAVENGERS AND CONSTRUCTION OF DRY LATRINES (PROHIBITION) ACT, 1993– This act outlawed the employment of individuals for manually cleaning human excreta. This is the first law that legally banned this practice of manual scavenging in India. The 1993 act paved the way for the new law, which was the Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013: This act prohibited manual scavenging in all forms and provided for rehabilitation efforts.
Case Study of Meerut City
If we see data provided by MS Survey, 2018 then it very evident that Uttar Pradesh has the highest estimated number of manual scavenger which is 64,785. Also, the data provided by the Socio Economic and Caste Census (SECC) (2011) in the article – ‘The grim reality of manual scavenging in India: A human rights perspective ‘by Garima Chawla, it shows that the number of manual scavenger household in Uttar Pradesh is 37,379. As mentioned in Chapter 6 of ‘Development Economics’ by Debraj Ray –What is economic Inequality? ‘It defines economic inequality as the fundamental disparity that permits one individual certain material choices, while denying another individual those very same choices’. The very same pattern is associated with the people engaged in the employment of Manual Scavenging.
The Problem of Income and the associated reasons for underdevelopment of Manual Scavenger.
What I understood from the various articles and books ‘Manual Scavengers Apathetic State and Callous Society by K.B. Saxena’ and ‘The Long March to Eliminate Manual Scavenging by Bezwada Wilson & Bhasha Singh’ I have taken up during writing this paper is that they are not able to come out of above a certain boundary when it comes to a basic income in their households. From the case study of Meerut City in Uttar Pradesh it shows how much a manual scavenger is earning as a daily wage worker in the occupation of manual scavenging. The people working in the Municipal corporations relatively get paid in the month’s end but if we see the same situation in the rural setting, it is kind of different one. In rural setting, they all are divided among different households and are accountable for cleaning those assigned house. They get a meagre amount of Rs 200 per day. Women on the other hand engaging in manual scavenging were get paid Rs. 50 – Rs 100/- of the full service of cleaning human waste. Sometimes, they are forced to take leftover food as an alternative to the money.
No Land or Little land holding
The study carried out by Dr. Anil in his paper ‘Socio-Economic Conditions of Manual Scavenger: A Study of Meerut City’ examines the physical environment of an individual engaged in manual scavenging as a profession. In his study he has found out that a kutcha construction is there where there is mixed material of mud, grass and thatch. On the other hand, the roof of pucca construction in the vicinity where the manual scavengers resides was found of wood, burned bricks, broken tiles, stones. The comparison done between the kutcha and the pucca houses belonging to people engaged in manual scavenging is somehow very significant because this reflect the housing condition of the people who earn a meagre amount. The number of people residing in a kutcha house is more than the number of people living in the pucca house. This comparison clearly shows that the living conditions of those communities who clean our environment have not improved yet.
Lack of Alternative Job
The study found that the lack of alternative livelihood options, and social stigma lead individuals to not stepping out of this old age traditional job. In the article written by Garima Chawla ‘The grim reality of manual scavenging in India: A human rights perspective’ she points out the families who engage in practice of manual scavenging has no or has little possession such as resources, property, valuables. They do not possess any land or housing in their name which makes it difficult for the families at the lowest level to even apply for loans from the government institutions.
Women in the Occupation – The most significant workforce
In this occupation women face double oppression here as they face exploitation on the basis of gender and on the basis of their caste as well. Women are responsible for the 95 per cent work done in the vocation of manual scavenging. In the urban setting of cities and metropolitans, men are assigned to work in the sewage tank, drains etc but in the rural setting of village women are responsible for doing the scavenging with their bare hands or with minimal technical and mechanical gears to prevent them getting infections etc.
In her book Gendering Caste: Through a feminist lens Uma Chakravarti says a Dalit women faces exploitation at three levels Caste, Class and Gender. Here it is very evident that women involved in manual scavenging faces discrimination at the hands of people belonging to the upper social locations, women often get sexually harass while doing their work as a scavenger and also faces mental and verbal abuses as well. Women working as a manual scavenger and also need to go back to their households to fulfill their responsibility as a homemaker as defined by the patriarchal norms. A woman manual scavenger, has to look after her house, her children, her elders present in the family. Whereas a man who work as a manual scavenger only comes back to home after work, he just comes home and relax. This is what 95 per cent entailed workforce of women looks like. Women work as manual scavengers in the day and as a machine at night. According to International Labor Organisation report ‘The ILO and Manual Scavengers in India: Paving the long way towards the elimination of discrimination based on social origin’ the vocation of manual scavenging is strictly held by women in India. According to the government estimates in 2005, 95 per cent of a total of 700,000 manual scavengers were women.
Conclusion
This paper was written with the faith that there is an intersection of poverty with caste & gender with focus on their income with the special reference to manual scavenging in India. After the independence the post Nehru period emphasized on the development of agriculture and later that on industries. However the post – independent period lack its emphasis on the internal social problems that were exiting even before the independence and even after the independence. The problems the stereotypes related to caste based occupation needed a much more emphasis because due to the negligence the community which remained at the lowest section of the society still remained there. The community of manual scavenging were not able to develop themselves because of social norms, taboos, stigmas, derogatory abuses. Manual scavengers were not able to come out of this poverty which made them poor with time. They were not able to earn a sustainable amount of basic and decent income thorough out their life because they ended up getting trapped in the vicious and ferocious circle of poverty.
References
- India. (1993). The Employment of Manual Scavengers and Construction of Dry Latrines(Prohibition) Act.
- India. (2013). The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and Their Rehabilitation Act
- The State and Urban Violence Against Marginalized Castes: ManualScavenging in India Today V. Ramaswamy & V. Srinivasan Chapter.
- Migration and Human Development in India Deshingkar, Priya and Akter, Shaheen MPRA
- The grim reality of manual scavenging in India: A human rights perspective Garima Chawla, Journal of Infrastructure, Policy and Development , 2024.
- The Long March to Eliminate Manual Scavenging Bezwada Wilson and Bhasha Singh , India Exclusion Report , 2012.
- Manual scavengers Apathetic state and callous society ByK. B. Saxena in Book Dalits, Subalternity and Social Change in India, Routledge 2018.
- Socio-Economic Conditions of Manual Scavenger: A Study of Meerut City by Dr. Anil Kumar ,Anubooks , 2022.
- Development Economic ,Debraj Ray , Oxford University Presss, 1998.
- https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-67191131
- https://nskfdc.nic.in/en/content/home/ms-survey-2018
- https://secc.gov.in/getMainSrcOfHhdIncomeRuralNationalReport.htm
- https://ili.ac.in/pdf/paper3.pdf
- https://www.hrw.org/report/2014/08/25/cleaning-human-waste/manual-scavenging-caste-and-discrimination-india
- https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/1581/1/199346.pdf
- https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1844974
- https://idsn.org/key-issues/manual-scavenging/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CWe%20have%20land%20on%20paper,take%20your%20land%20or%20not.%E2%80%9D
- https://www.epw.in/engage/article/manual-scavenging-women-face-double-discrimination-caste-gender
Author’s Bio
Komal is a first year research scholar currently pursuing her Ph.D. at School of Development Studies, Ambedkar University, Delhi. Her research interest revolves around the issues of caste, gender and labour. She is deeply committed to social justice as she seeks to address t he structural inequalities faced by the marginal communities of the society. Through, academic investigation, community engagement and social realities, Komal aspires to contribute to meaningful change and advocate for equity and dignity for all.




