Invisible Intersections: Tribals and Muslim Minorities in Jharkhand’s Development Discourse | Dr. Rajeev Kumar | Dr. S. M. Abbas

Abstract

This article shows how current development frameworks fail to include mixed and culturally diverse identities, focusing on the overlapping challenges faced by the Muslim minority and tribal groups in Jharkhand. It looks at how public policy categories like Scheduled Tribes and religious minorities often work separately, leaving out expatriate communities and tribal-Muslim converts. It explores the limitations of public policy classifications, including Scheduled Tribes and religious minorities, which often operate in isolation, thereby excluding expatriate communities and tribal-Muslim converts. There are ongoing issues with access to welfare, legal recognition, and inclusion that match SDG-10 when looking at traditional government systems, informal justice methods, and documentation. The paper emphasises the fundamental shortcomings of standardised welfare systems and highlights the obscurity of blended identities. In the end, the paper supports an intersectional policy framework that accepts various identity conceptions, integrates conventional legal systems, and promotes data disaggregation for equitable and inclusive development.

Keywords: Intersectional Marginalization, Tribal-Muslim Identity, Pasmanda Muslims, Sarna Code Movement, SDG-10

Rethinking Inclusion in Jharkhand: Towards Intersectional Governance

Jharkhand, founded in 2000 as a tribal homeland, exemplifies the constitutional commitment to acknowledge and elevate Adivasi groups. Nonetheless, Muslim minorities and tribal Muslim converts —faces certain challenges  in the inflexible classifications such as Scheduled Tribes or religious minorities (Mukherjee, 2018; Gupta, 2024). This inflexible perspective sustains their marginalization from welfare programs, legal protections, and democratic participation.

Pasmanda Muslims, as of now categorized as Dalit and OBC, represent the predominant segment of India’s margnalized Muslim demography,. Bureaucratic centralization has concurrently undermined indigenous governance frameworks such as Parha Raj, diminishing community-oriented decision-making (Prakash, 2007; Gupta, 2024). tribe–Muslim converts encounter dual disadvantages due to their religious identity: they are ineligible for tribe privileges, and their minority rights are inadequate (Mukherjee, 2018).

Grassroots initiatives like the Sarna Code movement contest the state’s inclination to standardize indigenous religions, advocating for official acknowledgment of varied spiritual practices (Mukherjee, 2018). Excluding caste groups—Ashraf, Ajlaf, and Arzal—from census data and resource allocation exacerbates disparities within the society. These blind spots highlight the imperative for intersectional policies, comprehensive data disaggregation, and participatory governance changes.

To achieve Sustainable Development Goal 10, which aims to reduce inequalities, policymakers should adopt inclusive approaches that formally recognize and support indigenous institutions. These refer to the traditional social, cultural, political, and economic systems that are rooted in the historical and lived experiences of tribal communities. In the case of the tribal Muslim minority in Jharkhand, such institutions often represent a unique blend of tribal customs and Islamic traditions, shaping community identity, internal governance, and everyday social practices. Recognizing and integrating these indigenous institutions into formal governance frameworks enables culturally sensitive policymaking, enhances local participation, and strengthens the legitimacy of state interventions. Alongside this, authorities should ensure that all social groups, especially marginalized communities, have fair and proportional representation in decision-making processes. It is equally important to introduce gender-sensitive reforms that address systemic inequalities and promote equal opportunities for people of all genders. These steps are essential for building a more just and inclusive society. Constitutional recognition of multifaceted identities and systematic data collection are crucial for converting rhetorical promises into equal outcomes (Bara, 2017; Kumari, 2024; Chaudhary & Tigga, 2023).

Advancing Pluralistic Governance in Jharkhand: Addressing Dual Marginalization

The tribal population of Jharkhand, constituting around 26 per cent of the state, is deprived of secure land tenure, quality education, and essential healthcare due to historical dispossession, inadequately funded welfare programs, and delays in the enforcement of the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006. Bureaucratic overreach and development paradigms that neglect cultural sovereignty have further undermined Indigenous self-governance frameworks, such as Parha Raj (Prakash, 2007).

Pasmanda Muslims, categorized as Dalits and Other Backward Classes, represent the predominant segment of India’s Muslim population; nonetheless, they are systematically marginalized from leadership roles and economic empowerment initiatives. In Jharkhand, communities such as Ansaris, Qureshis, and Kasais predominantly participate in agricultural labor and artisanal crafts; however, they receive minimal assistance from minority welfare programs (Gupta, 2023).

Tribal–Muslim converts often find themselves excluded from both tribal and minority welfare policies. Once they convert to Islam, they lose legal recognition as members of Scheduled Tribes and are no longer eligible for the benefits and protections meant for tribal communities. Furthermore, in many rural pockets of Jharkhand, core tribal groups—particularly followers of the Sarna faith—tend to ostracize those who embrace other religions. This social exclusion deepens their marginalization and further limits their access to welfare entitlements and community-based support networks. Together, these factors compound their vulnerability and institutional neglect. At the same time, their tribal background means they do not fully fit into the category of mainstream religious minorities, who receive support under separate minority welfare schemes. This policy gap leaves them without adequate safeguards, making their social and economic challenges largely invisible and unaddressed (Mukherjee, 2018). 

Movements such as the Sarna Code advocate for the institutional acknowledgement of Indigenous religions, opposing the state’s standardization of spiritual practices. The Ashraf–Ajlaf–Arzal hierarchy within Muslim groups is similarly excluded from census statistics and welfare allocation, exacerbating intra-community disparities (Gupta, 2023).

To uphold – policymakers must establish disaggregated data systems, constitutionally acknowledge hybrid religious identities, and formulate affirmative policies that surpass monolithic classifications.

Advancing Customary Justice in Jharkhand: An Advocacy Agenda

Traditional governance structures like Parha Raj, a council of elders rooted in Adivasi cosmologies, are essential for land management and conflict resolution in Jharkhand (Mukherjee, 2018). Muslim communities similarly depend on informal institutions such as the Jamaat and Darul Qaza to resolve issues related to marriage, property, and communal disputes, particularly within Pasmanda groups (Kumari, 2024). Their extralegal status makes verdicts reversible by state authority and excludes them from official court systems.

Patriarchal gatekeeping exacerbates the marginalization of tribal and Muslim women, compelling them to select between inaccessible formal judicial systems and community-based solutions that frequently disregard gender-sensitive and human rights criteria (Kumar & Madhuri, 2021; Mukherjee, 2018). The disparity between statutory law and actual conditions expands under the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996, as deficient Gram Sabha consultations about land and resource matters are predominantly symbolic (Bara, 2017).

Policymakers must formalize and incorporate customary bodies into a pluralistic justice system, guaranteeing legal legitimacy, gender-responsive reforms, and adherence to constitutional protections. This pivotal measure is crucial for diminishing inequalities as stipulated by SDG 10 and for safeguarding the rights of hybrid-identity groups in Jharkhand.

Embedding Intersectionality into Jharkhand’s Governance: A Call to Action

The existing governance structure in Jharkhand, based on inflexible classifications, systematically marginalizes hybrid identities—such as tribal-Muslim converts and culturally syncretic communities—from access to welfare and political representation. An intersectional development paradigm, rooted in cultural awareness and legal reform, is crucial for dismantling these complex hurdles (Mukherjee, 2018; Kumari, 2024).

Initially, it is imperative to formally acknowledge and enhance customary justice institutions, such as Parha Raj councils for Adivasi groups and informal jamaat or darul qaza forums within Muslim society. Despite functioning beyond statutory law and lacking gender-sensitive protections, these entities provide accessible, community-oriented dispute resolution (Mukherjee, 2018; Kumari, 2024).

Secondly, authorities ought to require the collection of disaggregated data that includes caste, religious affiliation, customary governance relationships, and gender. Without such nuanced datasets, aid programs may reinforce existing hierarchies and exclude the most marginalized (Gupta, 2024). Partnerships with academic institutions can guarantee strong, intersectional metrics.

Third, substantial participatory governance mechanisms must include grassroots innovations—such as community-driven health campaigns and municipal justice initiatives—into state planning. Collaboratively developed frameworks will improve policy significance and stakeholder ownership (Chaudhary & Tigga, 2023).

Ultimately, the formal recognition of syncretic identities is essential. The Sarna Code movement advocates for the explicit classification of indigenous spiritual identities and the acknowledgement of internal Muslim caste hierarchies—Ashraf, Ajlaf, and Arzal—necessitating reforms in census and resource allocation (Mukherjee, 2018; Gupta, 2024). By formalizing customary institutions, organizing disaggregated data, and maintaining constitutional safeguards, Jharkhand can realize its commitment under SDG 10 to mitigate inequality and respect its diverse heritage.

Conclusion

The way things are developing in Jharkhand shows how structural limitations continue when policy frameworks do not take into account intersectional identities and traditional ways of running things. There are systemic blind spots in laws, welfare programs, and statistics that make it challenging for tribal groups and Muslim minorities to get the help they need. This is especially true for people who live in cultural or religious spaces that are not strictly Muslim. These exclusions make it harder for people to be seen in society, for the law to be stable, and for indigenous and mixed-up ways of knowing to be included in public conversations.

Though customary justice systems like Parha Raj and informal arbitration bodies in Muslim communities show resilience and local legitimacy, they are not a big part of mainstream government because they are not standardized and do not take gender into account (Mukherjee, 2018; Kumari, 2024). At the same time, groups like the Sarna Code show that religious categorization is flawed and raise the issue of demanding constitutional recognition of spiritual autonomy (Mukherjee, 2018). Similarly, differences in Muslim social classes based on castes (Ajlaf, Ashraf, and Arzal) are not shown in policy documents, which makes it harder for everyone to attain the help they need (Gupta, 2024).

Sustainable growth Goal 10 calls for growth that benefits everyone. For Jharkhand to reach this goal, governance must accept pluralism both in words and actions. This means officially recognizing hybrid identities, changing traditional organizations, and creating separate data systems that show how people’s lives are in terms of culture and society. The best way to reduce inequality and respect Jharkhand’s diverse social fabric is through an integrated, participatory framework that is based on local opinions, legal reform, and intersectional justice.

Dr. Rajeev Kumar is an Assistant Professor, ICFAI University, Jharkhand, Ranchi. He is a PhD (Social Sciences) from IIT Kharagpur, recipient of UGC-JRF, and MSW from TISS Mumbai; he brings 15+ years of experience in research, teaching, and NGO collaboration focused on gender development, tribal development, nutrition, public health, and sustainability, shaping impactful frameworks for marginalized communities through interdisciplinary practice. Email: [email protected] 

Dr. S. M. Abbas is a Associate Professor & Head,  Department of Anthropology, Dr Shyama Prasad Mukherjee University, Ranchi, India. He is a seasoned anthropologist with decades of research, teaching, and administrative experience, is acclaimed for his work in tribal development, social work, and Muslim minority affairs, with global academic presentations and extensive publications to his credit. Email: [email protected]

References

Bara, J. (2017). Tribes in India: Identity, Culture, and Development. Rawat Publications. https://www.rawatbooks.com/book_detail.php?bookid=1016

Chaudhary, S., & Tigga, L. (2023). Pluralism and tribal governance in Jharkhand. Indian Journal of Social Justice, 17(2), 105–124. https://ijsj.in/pluralism-tribal-governance/

Government of India. (1996). The Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996. https://legislative.gov.in/actsofparliamentfromtheyear/panchayats-extension-scheduled-areas-act-1996

Government of India. (2006). Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006. https://legislative.gov.in/actsofparliamentfromtheyear/scheduled-tribes-and-other-traditional-forest-dwellers

Gupta, S. (2023). Invisible Muslims: Caste, tribe, and politics of recognition in India. Journal of Minority Studies, 14(3), 101–123. https://doi.org/10.1177/0971945823123542

Gupta, S. (2024). Invisible Muslims: Caste, tribe, and politics of recognition in India. Journal of Minority Studies, 15(1), 67–89. https://doi.org/10.1177/0971945823123542

Kumar, R., & Madhuri. (2021). Witch-hunting: A mute atrocity against indigenous women. In W. Leal Filho, A. M. Azul, L. Brandli, A. L. Salvia, P. G. Ă–zuyar, & T. Wall (Eds.), Peace, justice and strong institutions (Encyclopedia of the UN Sustainable Development Goals). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-71066-2_141-1

Kumari, B. (2024). Intersectionality and development policy in Jharkhand. Policy and Governance Review, 12(1), 88–109. https://policygovreview.org/articles/intersectionality-jharkhand/

Mukherjee, A. (2018). Religious conversions and tribal identity in Jharkhand. South Asia Journal of Politics, 22(3), 141–159. https://southasiajournal.net/religious-conversion-tribal-jharkhand/

Prakash, A. (2007). Indigenous governance and bureaucratic absorption: The case of Parha Raj. Journal of Political Anthropology, 4(2), 55–74. https://www.jpolanth.org/indigenous-parha-raj/

 

 

Share