Intersectional Exclusions: Gender, Minority and the Voices of Muslim Women in India | Rabiul Molla

Minority Muslim women in India are systematically excluded from the policy-making, legal framework, social and political discourses, often by the state mechanism and or by the gender dynamics from within or outside the community, while they consistently seek to raise their voices in political, social, cultural and religious discourses. During the partition and integration of the princely states, Nehru and Patel assured minority Muslims that the state would protect their rights in every aspect. But in the post-colonial era, Muslim women are facing marginalization in the context of gender, religion and minority identity in their own democratic nation, besides their community, while the constitution promises gender equality, justice, and rights of minorities. The participation of Muslim women in the movement for independence was quite eye-catching. Muslim women like Begum Hazrat Mahal, Zubaida Daoodi, Azizan, Amjadi Begum and Sadat Banu Kichlew joined both non-violent as well as violent movements against colonial rule, besides encouraging their husbands, fathers and sons to take an active part in India’s freedom movement (Badruddin, 2018). Though the conditions of Muslim women in the colonial period faced restrictions on taking education, limited mobility through the Zenana system, and early marriages. The reform movements gradually advocated for their education, breaking the Zenana system, discouragement of early marriages, social participation and rights.  However, in the post-colonial democratic India, their voices have often been suppressed, misrepresented, silenced and or marginalized in the policy making, legal framework, social and political discourses. Scholars like Zoya Hasan, Flavia Agnes, and journalist Seema Mustafa have drawn attention to the social exclusion of Muslim women and appropriate action to address under-representation and exclusion. It is worth exploring how socially vulnerable sections, like Muslim women, have fared in the sphere of political empowerment within India’s liberal, democratic political and institutional framework (Kidwai and Ghosh, 2025).

In the seventy-five years after liberation from colonial rule, there are no provisions in the constitution, reserving women’s seats at the Upper or Lower House in the parliament. However, Article 243D and 243T of the Indian Constitution provide not less than one-third reservation for women out of the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in every Panchayat and Municipality (Rajya Sabha, 2023). But these provisions fail to reserve seats, particularly for Muslim women, to raise their voices. In this context, the evolving relationship between the Indian state and Muslim women explores how minority identity and gender dynamics have often been intersectionally excluded in political, social and religious matters. Through key legal battles, political and social movements, it maps the rising assertion of Muslim women’s voices in India. The relationship between minority, gender and state highlights the theoretical framework, ‘Intersectional Political Exclusion’ by Kimberlé Crenshaw, underlined by factors such as gender, religion, and minority status. As Kimberlé Crenshaw argued, “Race, gender, and other identity categories are most often treated in mainstream liberal discourse as vestiges of bias or domination—that is, as intrinsically negative frameworks in which social power works to exclude or marginalize those who are different” (Crenshaw, 1991). The difference mentioned by Crenshaw is also visible in Indian identity politics, where Muslim women increasingly face marginalization by the state in terms of gender and minority status. These gender and minority differentiations often limited their access to state-dominated political and social discourses.

 

The first major policy contradiction in post-colonial India was between Muslim women and the state, with the issue of religious personal laws. India adopted the model of legal and constitutional pluralism, allowing religious communities such as Muslims to govern their own family matters like marriage, divorce, inheritance, property matters, and maintenance.

‘The Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act of 1937’ continued to apply, even after independence, in Muslim society. While Hindu personal laws were codified, reformed, and reinstituted within 1955-56—securing rights such as divorce and inheritance for Hindu women, the Muslim personal law was not touched intentionally by the state. The state’s reluctance to intervene was driven partly by fears of antagonising the Muslim community and clergy, and partly by a desire to appear neutral toward religious minority communities.

Such non-intervention by the state, however, effectively allowed misinterpretations and misrepresentations of Islamic law to manipulate and dominate Muslim women’s lives in the household and public domains, particularly leaving them unvoiced. Zoya Hasan argues that the failure to reform Muslim personal law reflected the state’s “politics of avoidance”—a strategy that shielded patriarchal norms in the name of respecting minority autonomy (Hasan, 2009), which did not empower Muslim women but kept them bound to an outdated legal framework interpreted almost exclusively by male religious scholars.

The inadequacies of legal, secular and constitutional pluralism became starkly visible and challenged in the ‘Shah Bano Case of 1985’. A sixty-two-year-old Muslim woman, Saha Banu from Indore, Madhya Pradesh, was divorced by her husband, Mohd. Ahmed Khan was left without financial assistance following the ‘Muslim Personal Law’. She approached the local court to the Supreme Court under ‘Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code’, a national and secular law that will be applied to every citizen without justifying anyone’s religious identity, which mandates that the men are bound to provide finances as maintenance to his divorced spouse if she cannot financially support herself. The Supreme Court gave a judgment in her favour, upholding her right to maintenance and urging the union government to enact an ‘Uniform Civil Code’ to ensure justice, over gender across all religious communities, without any discrimination. The verdict sparked an uproar among conservative Muslim leaders, who viewed the judgment as interference in religious affairs by the Court. In response to the Court, Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi’s led Congress Party government was willing to enact a ‘Uniform Civil Code’, but facing rigorous opposition from within the Muslim community, the government passed the ‘Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act of 1986’, effectively overturning the Court’s judgment, while those Muslim MPs were fragmented over the matter. This law restricted or narrowed Muslim women’s rights to maintenance after divorce, pushing the responsibility onto her close relatives or the Muslim Waqf Board, while in judgment of the Court gave a translucent direction that the responsibility be pushed upon the husband. Feminists and legal scholars condemned the act as a blatant appeasement of patriarchal forces under the guise of secularism by the state. Muslim women were spoken for, but never consulted. Their constitutional rights were subordinated to political calculations and male-dominated religious authority, as Flavia Agnes has argued that the Shah Bano case exposed how both religious conservatism and state policy could align to curtail women’s rights (Agnes, 1999).

Amongst the most enduring challenges for Muslim women in India is the underrepresentation in politics and political institutions. Despite constituting a significant number of the country’s female population, Muslim women are nearly invisible in both the House of Parliament and the state’s legislatures. Unlike caste-based reservations, there is no provision for minority women, and the ‘Women’s Reservation Bill’, passed in 2023 but not in effective, still lacks a mechanism for sub-quotas for Muslim women. In the Panchayat and Municipality Bodies, reservations for women are provided in self-government by the 73rd and 74th Constitution amendments. However, these do not guarantee political representation for Muslim women in proportion to their population. Moreover, socio-economic barriers, communal prejudice, and lack of party backing often prevent them from contesting or winning elections. Muslim women have been made predominantly in the context of gender relations, focusing on their perennial plight as subjugated, oppressed and unaware, as being victims of societal malice (Kidwai and Ghosh, 2025). Muslim women are not only underrepresented in politics but also in bureaucracies, media, judiciary, and academia—leaving their voices largely unheard in national discourse, policy-making and legal framework. This democratic deficit reinforces stereotypes and allows others—politicians, clerics, or NGOs—to speak on their behalf.

The lack of Muslim women in the parliament or aversion to politics has often been responsible for securing their rights. Most of them are largely marginalized, faceless and voiceless in their own social circle, due to social stigma or otherwise, they are virtually kept silent to speak their wishes and views instead of opting for open choice (Badruddin, 2018). Since independence, few Muslim women have been elected to the parliament, like Maimoona Sultan, Syeda Anwara Taimur, Sabana Azmi, Najma Heptulla, Mehbooba Mufti, Tabassum Begum, Rashida Haque, Sultana Raza and Jannat Jahan, while Muslims are demographically the second largest community and the first largest minority community in India. The reasons behind this, according to the Sachar Committee Report (2006), the Ranganath Misra Commission (2007), and the Post-Sachar Evaluation Report (2014), which highlight the lower literacy rate, poor access to education, and economic disparities among Muslims, and Muslim women are not exceptions to this poor development. Recent controversy about Triple Talaq, Love Jihad, Ghar Wapsi (Back to Hinduism) and Suddhikaran (purification), miserably spread by the Indian media and ruling rightist forces, has resulted in serious controversies (Badruddin, 2018). A sufficient number of Muslim women’s representation in parliament and politics would force the state to listen to them. The voices of Muslim women would be expected to affect the state mechanism, gender dynamics and minority status within or outside the community, and influence the vibrant legal framework, policy-making, political and social discourses. These voices ensure their rights, besides their upliftment in education and economic development. However, in the recent parliament, there is not a significant number of Muslim women’s representation, causing a lack of their voices against the dominant state machinery. There have been several efforts to introduce women’s reservation in the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies, and the last such attempt was made in 2010, when the Rajya Sabha had passed a Bill for women’s reservation, but the same could not be passed in the Lok Sabha (The Gazette of India, 2023). In 2023, the Lok Sabha passed a Bill for women’s reservation in Parliament, State Legislature and the UT of Delhi, but it has not been implemented. Women’s Reservation Bill 2023 might affect the participation of Muslim women, but the Bill lacks a particular reservation for minority women.

References
  1. Abidi, A. (2013). Muslim Women and Their Representation in South Asian Politics. Islam and Muslim Societies: A Social Science Journal, 6(2), 11-27. https://www.muslimsocieties.org/Vol6_2/Muslim_Women_and_their_Representation.pdf
  2. Agnes, F. (1999). Law and Gender Inequality: The Politics of Women’s Rights in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
  3. Ahmed, H. (2014). Muslim Political Discourse in Postcolonial India: Monuments, Memory, Contestation. Routledge.
  4. Badruddin. (2018). Muslim Women in India: A Media Perception. 13th International Conference on Economics, Education, Humanities & Social Sciences Studies, (pp. 79-81). Pattaya (Thailand). doi: https://doi.org/10.17758/EARES3.EAP0818423
  5. Crenshaw, K. (1991). Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review, 1241-1299. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1229039
  6. Hasan, Z. (2009). Politics of Inclusion: Castes, Minorities, and Affirmative Action. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
  7. Kidwai, R., & Ghosh, A. K. (2025). Missing from the House. New Delhi: Juggernaut Books.
  8. Lok Sabha Secretariat. (2023, September 19). The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-eighth Amendment) Bill, 2023. The Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 2. Government of India. https://egazette.gov.in/WriteReadData/2023/248832.pdf
  9. Rajya Sabha Secretariat. (2023). Written answer by the Minister of State for Panchayati Raj regarding reservation for women in Panchayats. Sansad. https://sansad.in/getFile/annex/260/AU722.pdf?source=pqars 
  10. Zoya, H. (Ed.). (2020). Forging Identities: Gender, Communities, and the State in India. Routledge.

Author’s Bio:

Rabiul Molla is currently pursuing his Doctoral Studies in the Department of History at Rabindra Bharati University, Kolkata. His areas of interest include Gender and Minority Studies, Tribal Studies, the History of Science and Technology, Public Health and Urban Management, as well as Modern and Contemporary India.

Share