Beyond The Legal Facade Of Flexibility: Analysing The Sustainability Of Classifying Gig Workers As Independent Contractors In Ride-Hailing And Food Delivery Companies | Navdeep Singh

Abstract

The new type of economic arrangement, called the gig economy, has introduced significant alterations in legal work relationships since it introduced platform-based work, which has created ambiguities over the status of gig workers in such an employment structure. Gig Economy companies classify their workers as independent contractors, which allows them to surpass the legal protections which are available to employees in traditional employment structures. By particularly focusing on food delivery and Ride-hailing companies, the following will analyse the basis of such classification. It asserts that despite presumed autonomy and independence, these platforms exercise significant control over their workers, which indicates that these workers have been misclassified to extract maximum profits. It intends to highlight that the ambiguities inherent in classifying gig workers have led to arbitrary suppression of their legal rights and therefore emphasise the need for legal reform in the direction of a more equitable system. 

Introduction

Law is a living phenomenon. It changes with external circumstances and always strives to correspond to the existing realities of the jurisdiction in which it is applied. A stagnant law is bound to become obsolete and unworkable. In the 21st century, this change is speedier than ever. Such a change brings new challenges that the law must address. Often in the course of addressing a new issue, the law must diverge from its established principles and long-standing practices. In recent years, a new phenomenon known as the gig economy has come into being, which is essentially a product of the development of digital platforms and technology.[1][2]The old legal framework has been seriously challenged by the new kind of employment relationship that is created in such a system. It affects the labour law protections, which are applicable in traditional employment relationships, but not in the Gig Economy.[3]

Despite presumed autonomy and independence, these platforms exercise significant control over their workers, which indicates that these workers have been misclassified to extract maximum profits.

What Is The Gig Economy?

The gig economy is a new type of work arrangement where the workforce is involved in freelancing and side-hustle work.[4] Simply put, the gig economy uses various digital platforms that serve as middlemen to exchange labour on a task-by-task basis for a brief period of time between consumers and suppliers.  One of the most important features of the gig economy is the flexibility of work and independence, in contrast with the traditional employment relationships. It allows employers to access the specialised skills of these workers by avoiding long-term economic commitments. [5] The gig economy is thriving. As per a survey conducted by McKinsey in 2022, almost 27 per cent of the workforce in the United States of America, which is nearly 58 million people, are involved in such an employment setup. [6]

Various digital ride-hailing and food delivery companies are two important sectors of the gig economy that affect our daily lives.[7] The ride-hailing app, like Uber, uses this kind of atypical model of employing drivers. When a passenger requests Uber, the software finds the closest available driver who is under contract with the company. Depending on his objectives, the driver is free to turn down the offer. The platform and the driver split the money that the user pays.[8] Indian food delivery apps such as Swiggy and Zomato follow the same model, which has revolutionised the food delivery mechanism. These apps provide a full catalogue of restaurants from which the customers can choose. The food is delivered by delivery partners hired by these organisations.[9]

The gig economy is flourishing in India as a result of rising smartphone usage, cheap internet, and a number of other factors.[10] According to NITI Aayog, there are already 7.7 million Indians working in the gig and platform-based economy, and by 2029–2030, the number is projected to increase to 23.5 million. Additionally, 22% of workers can be placed into the highly skilled category, while 47% are medium-skilled, and 31% are low-skilled.[11]

Legal Status Of Workers In the Gig Economy

The 2020 Code on Social Security defines a gig worker as an individual who does work or is involved in a labour arrangement and receives compensation from such activities, which is outside the conventional employer-employee relationship. Gig workers are therefore not regarded as employees. In gig economies, businesses often take the view that they are not service providers but technology providers. It means that the fundamental position of these platforms between the client and the worker is of a provider of a platform which connects these workers with the users. It allows these businesses to classify these gig workers as independent contractors, which allows such businesses to take an advantageous position by avoiding expenses associated with characterising such workers as employees. However, the position that these platforms are merely a provider of technology is controversial and often invites significant criticism.[12] 

The economy is new and recent, and therefore, Indian courts are yet to deliver on the rights of such workers. India lacks any specific statute to protect such gig workers.[13]  The 2020 Code on Social Security was seen as a beacon of hope for these workers since it acknowledges the gig and platform-based workers and ensures benefits like health, disability, and life insurance.[14] However, the legal framework surrounding the gig workers remains ambiguous, hindering the legal rights of gig workers. Therefore, it has become necessary to regulate the gig economy to extend essential safeguards to these workers, similar to those of employees, under various labour laws.[15]

However, since the gig economy relationship is comparable to both an employee and an independent contractor, it is incorrect to classify gig workers entirely as independent contractors. The terms and circumstances of their work are governed by a contract, much like with independent contractors. They perform the same duty as a regular employee. This technical designation of independent contractors given to these workers increases the profitability of these business models, but renders these workers vulnerable to exploitation.[16] 

Why Gig Workers Are Not Independent Contractors?

Over the years, several tests have been devised to investigate the distinction between an independent contractor and an employee. However, the application of these tests has often led to subjective interpretations across various jurisdictions, often pronouncing conflicting outcomes.[17] However, when these tests are applied to determine the legal status of workers in ride-hailing and food-delivery companies, they provide us with a conflicting vision of how workers in these gig companies have been misclassified as independent contractors since they do not entirely fulfil the requirements of such classification. However, applying these tests in the gig economy does not intend to suggest that a relationship in a gig economy indicates an employer-employee relationship. 

I. Test Of Control

The traditional test that can be applied to ascertain the position of workers in gig-economies is the test of control, wherein the courts look at whether the master exercised control over the worker not only in matters of what is to be done, but also in supervising and controlling how it is done. The master can apply such control in case of employees, but the procedure being adopted to carry out the work to produce a certain result is at the discretion of the independent contractor. If the master controls the methods by which the worker plans to work, then there is an employer-employee relationship.

Even though gig workers are categorised as independent contractors, gig economy businesses exercise significant control over the procedure adopted by these workers through their terms and conditions, which include the ability of the company to terminate the contract and temporarily suspend the workers’ accounts. Zomato forbids delivery partners from delegating any responsibility to a third party. When these delivery partners exhibit subpar performance or inactivity for longer than 21 days, Zomato retains the right to terminate the agreement.  The contract can be terminated if the delivery partners are found to be engaged in any such act which can cause legal or contractual liability for Zomato.[18] Further, Uber reserves the right to suspend the account of delivery partners for things like making discriminatory and offensive comments, poor ride experience, low ratings, etc.[19] Combined, these companies assume a position where they exercise substantial control over the discretionary conduct of these workers, which is a key aspect of the employer-employee relationship. 

The control that is being exercised is substantial in light of the control that is usually exercised on independent contractors, where they are asked to produce a particular result, i.e., to deliver food or to provide transportation service, and have complete discretion on the manner it is to be done. Therefore, when the test of control is applied to the workers in the gig economy, it is apparent that the classification of gig workers as independent contractors in these ride-hailing and Food-Delivery Companies is not appropriate. 

The legal framework surrounding the gig workers remains ambiguous, hindering the legal rights of gig workers.

II. Economic Reality Test

The most important objective behind classifying gig workers as independent contractors is to get rid of the expenses related to an employer-employee relationship. To ascertain the legal connection between the worker and the hirer, the U.S. Department of Labour and several courts consider the “Economic Reality Test,” which takes into account multi-faceted factors.[20] The economic realities that exist between the worker and the hirer are examined to determine this connection. A worker is considered an independent contractor if the nature of his work suggests that he is running his own company, while he is deemed an employee when his financial reliance on their employer is evident. This approach takes a broader outlook in contrast with the traditional test of control. It takes into account the following factors, which should be considered in totality to determine the economic dependence and to ascertain the legal relationship between the worker and the hirer.[21]

  1. Opportunity to use of Managerial Skill for profit or loss: It looks into the opportunity that the workers to deliberate upon the renumeration they are getting, to decline or accept work as per convenience, can employ their workers or engages in other efforts to expand a business or secure more work, such as marketing or advertising. The ability to make such decisions makes a worker an independent contractor.[23] However, it has bleak applicability in the gig economy. Uber has a fixed price structure where drivers cannot ask for more than what has been determined by Uber. The liberty to refuse is not absolute and is subject to scrutiny by Uber. They are prohibited from delegating duties by sharing their account with others.[23]
  2. Investment: It takes into account independent entrepreneurial investment to increase the business, as the criterion to be classified as an independent contractor.[24] Food-delivery and Ride-hailing Companies in gig economies require these workers to use their vehicles.[25] Yet, these cannot be called investments since the objective is not to increase business, but it is a requirement to sustain employment in such an economic model.
  3. The Degree of Permanence: Independent Contractor status is indicated by a fixed period of the project, while an employee has a long-term relationship without any fixed ending date. [26] These employment pattern of gig companies shows a tilt towards employee status since most workers are in long-term association with these companies, where they carry out the work as per the nature of the company, without a fixed ending date of the project. 
  4. Degree and Nature of Control: One significant aspect of the test, which relies upon the traditional view of control, explores the control of the hirer on various aspects of his association with the worker, which includes recruitment, termination, determining pay rates, supervision over work performance, etc.[27] As stated above, the degree of control exercised in food-delivery and ride-hailing companies is substantial in comparison with independent contractors. 
  5. Importance of work performed for the employer’s business: It refers to what extent the work that is executed by such a worker is a central part of the business of the hirer. If the work is critical, it indicates an employer-employee relationship.[28] In Gig Economies, especially in food-delivery and ride-hailing companies, the work performed by these workers is the central aspect of the business model of these companies, without which they cannot sustain themselves. 
  6. Initiative and Skill: It looks into whether the worker uses skill together with growing a business. Both a worker and an independent contractor possess skills; therefore, what needs to be seen is whether a worker is exercising the skill from a perspective of business initiative.[29] In Gig Economies, these workers possess skills such as driving, yet no significant business initiative is involved since they have little opportunity to use their skills from the perspective of business generation or securing work from other companies. 

This multi-faceted test builds upon the historical pronouncements of the US Federal Courts.[30] First in 1947 with United States v. Silk, where the court observed that “employees included workers who were such as a matter of economic reality”, and further in  Rutherford Food Corp. v. McComb, it was held that the determinant of employee status is not the test of control, but to correct the underlying economic evils by looking at the underlying economic realities. The test reflects that classifying gig workers as independent contractors is not the correct position when all aspects of multifaceted criteria are considered in totality. 

III. A.B.C. Test

Following the decision of California’s Supreme Court in Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court of Los Angeles, A.B.C. test came into existence, which can be used to ascertain whether workers in a gig company are independent contractors or employees.[31] The test presumes that workers are employees and establishes three conditions that the hirer must prove to demonstrate that the worker is an independent contractor. 

The conditions that the hirer must prove to deny the presumption of workers as employees include that 

  1. The worker is free from the hirer’s control within the terms of the contract and while performing the act. 
  2. The act that the worker performs is not a part of the usual business of the hirer. 
  3. The worker is involved in an occupation, business or trade of a similar nature which aligns with the work that he is performing for the hirer.[32]

The established standard is essentially broken when workers in the gig economy are classified as independent contractors.

However, the established standard is essentially broken when workers in the gig economy are classified as independent contractors. The food delivery and ride-hailing apps exercise substantial control over the process of work through the terms of the contract and the rating system. The ratings given by the consumers are constantly monitored by these companies, and the workers with low ratings are terminated.[33] Further, the acts performed by these workers in these companies are an intrinsic part of the nature of the business of these platforms. Ride-hailing companies like Uber fundamentally depend on drivers, and food-sharing companies like Zomato cannot sustain themselves with these delivery partners since their model is to provide delivery, which is impossible without these workers. Additionally, research indicates that the vast majority of Uber drivers, i.e. 58.7 per cent, drive only for the company and primarily depend upon it for work, indicating that they do not own their businesses and rely solely on Uber for employment.[34]

What differentiates a contract for service and a contract of service is an extremely thin line. With the passage of time and societal modernisation, the test of control has become obsolete. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Silver Jubilee Tailoring House v. Chief Inspector of Shops observed that the traditional control test is not exclusive. The test of control remains an important criterion. However, it is not decisive in every case. With the emergence of new types of business structures, courts are facing issues in reconciling the traditional view with the modern problems. The Indian Federation of App-Based Transport Workers (IFAT) has challenged the status of “partners” before the Supreme Court of India on the ground that it violates Articles 14, 21, and 23 of the Constitution. They urge the Court to recognise workers in the gig economy as ‘unorganised workers’, thereby enabling them to access social security legislation. However, the matter remains pending, and a constitutional development may be anticipated.[35]

With the emergence of new types of business structures, courts are facing issues in reconciling the traditional view with the modern problems.

Suggestions And Conclusion 

Therefore, with the emergence of modern technology, a new kind of employment structure has been established in gig economies and has challenged traditionally established notions of a clear distinction between an employee and an independent contractor with clearly defined rights. Application of these tests in gig economies makes it clear that the classification of these workers simply as independent contractors is not sustainable. However, it is also important to recognise that they are not truly employees as well, since attributing employee status to workers in ride-hailing and food-delivery will destroy the profit-making model upon which these companies rely. Gig Economy breaks the assumption that only two extreme ends exist as far as the relationship between a worker and hirer is concerned, which does not hold in the era of technology. Law must reconcile its position to protect the legitimate economic interests of these gig-economy companies and preserve the constitutionally mandated principles of social, economic, and political justice[36] by ensuring that rights of workers in such economies are upheld and they are not subjected to exploitation. For the same reason, it is essential to extend labour law protections to these economies. However, an absolute extension is neither desirable nor maintainable, and therefore, it must be calculated with the attempt to harmonise the interests of both sides. It is suggested that a third category, a golden mean, can be created to ensure that these workers are given the most basic and essential rights and protections, while ensuring that the essence of the working model of such companies is not hindered. By creating such a balance, rights can be protected and economic development can be synchronised with them.   

About the Author: Navdeep Singh is a student of B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) at National University of Study and Research in Law, Ranchi. 

 

Share