Book Discussion | Pious Labor: Islam, Artisanship, and Technology in Colonial India by Dr. Amanda Marie Lanzillo

The Centre for Studies of Plural Societies (CSPS) hosted a deeply insightful and intellectually vibrant discussion on Pious Labor: Islam, Artisanship, and Technology in Colonial India by Dr. Amanda Marie Lanzillo on 21st January 2025. The event brought together scholars, students, and members of the public to engage with the intersections of labour, religion, and ethics within the historical context of Muslim artisanal communities in colonial India.

The session was chaired by Dr. P.C. Saidalavi, Assistant Professor at the School of Humanities and Social Sciences, Shiv Nadar University. He opened the discussion by highlighting the book’s critical intervention in labour history. Dr. Saidalavi noted that Pious Labor challenges secular-economic frameworks by foregrounding ethical and religious consciousness as central to the lived realities of work.

Dr. Amanda Lanzillo, Assistant Professor at the University of Chicago, then presented the key arguments of her book. She illustrated how Muslim artisans—such as metalworkers, tanners, butchers, and tailors—understood their labour as both livelihood and ethical-spiritual practice. Drawing on Islamic jurisprudence, Sufi traditions, and community texts, Dr. Lanzillo showed how artisans framed their work as a form of ibadah (worship), guided by principles of cleanliness, honesty, humility, and moral responsibility. She further examined how colonial governance, census classifications, and reformist discourses disrupted and reconfigured these practices, often reducing artisanal labour to bureaucratic or stigmatized categories.

In his response, Dr. Saeed Ahmad, Assistant Professor and Assistant Dean of Research at the Jindal School of Art and Architecture, OP Jindal Global University, praised the book’s interdisciplinary method, which weaves together archival research, theoretical analysis, and ethnographic sensitivity. He emphasized that Pious Labor resists simplistic binaries of secular/religious or material/spiritual, offering instead a textured account of labour as ethical, embodied, and socially embedded. At the same time, he raised critical questions on caste, gender, and the politics of purity, underscoring the need to situate artisanal ethics within broader structures of hierarchy and exclusion.

In his closing remarks, Dr. Saidalavi highlighted the broader significance of Pious Labor—not only for historians of South Asia but also for scholars and practitioners interested in reimagining labour as a site of ethical engagement and spiritual creativity. He underlined that the book invites us to rethink how we narrate, value, and live with labour in both historical and contemporary contexts.

The discussion that followed was both wide-ranging and stimulating. Participants reflected on the contemporary resonances of these ethical frameworks, especially in relation to informal economies, religious identity, and the politics of dignity and value. Methodological challenges of working with colonial archives and recovering marginalised voices were also explored, underscoring the stakes of writing labour histories attentive to ethics, memory, and community knowledge.

The event marked another meaningful step in CSPS’s commitment to fostering critical, plural, and interdisciplinary conversations around social justice, historical memory, and ethical life. CSPS extends its gratitude to Dr. Amanda Lanzillo, Dr. Saeed Ahmad, and Dr. P.C. Saidalavi for their generous insights and participation.

 

Share