On a quiet evening that quickly turned into a vibrant exchange of ideas, the Centre for Studies of Plural Societies (CSPS) hosted a deeply reflective book discussion on Grief and the Shaping of Muslim Communities in Colonial North India by Dr. Eve Tignol. Published by Cambridge University Press in 2023, the book explores how grief, not just as an emotion, but as an expression and political force, shaped the religious and communal life of North Indian Muslims under colonial rule.
The event brought together a small but engaged group of 21 out of 57 registered participants, creating an intimate space for thoughtful conversation. We were privileged to have three scholars with us whose work spans the intersections of emotion, history, gender, and Muslim identities across geographies and time.
The session opened with a warm welcome and felicitation, setting the tone for what followed. Dr. Tignol began by walking us through the central themes of her book. She spoke of grief not as a passive feeling, but as a dynamic force—shaping relationships, mobilising communities, and offering ways to respond to colonial violence, reformist debates, and religious fragmentation. Drawing from Urdu elegies, print periodicals, and reformist writings, she demonstrated how mourning rituals—majlis gatherings, marsiya poetry, and public laments—became powerful tools for community formation and ethical reflection.
What stood out in her talk was the nuanced attention to language and affect, and how these formed the texture of everyday life and collective memory. Dr. Tignol’s deep engagement with Urdu texts and her command of multiple North Indian languages added richness to her narrative.
Chairing the session was Dr. Azeemah Saleem, who brought in valuable insights on how emotion has often been left out of mainstream political histories. She situated the book within broader conversations around minority politics, migration, and Muslim identity, and praised its potential for cross-regional dialogues, particularly in contexts of forced displacement and exile.

The audience Q&A brought in a range of questions—from the relationship between grief and language, to how print cultures circulated mourning across different regions and publics. One participant asked whether we can think of grief as a form of political resistance, to which Dr. Tignol responded with reflections on how mourning has historically offered space for both healing and protest.
Though modest in size, the session was rich in content, layered in interpretation, and emotionally resonant. The conversation lingered long after the event ended.
We closed with a heartfelt thank-you to our speakers—Dr. Eve Tignol, Dr. Azeemah Saleem, and Dr. Sumaiyah Ahmed—for their time, generosity, and critical insights. We’re also grateful to everyone who joined us and participated in the conversation.
At CSPS, we continue to hold space for such dialogues that explore the many textures of human experience across disciplines, borders, and voices.
Mohammad Zaid
Program Officer
